October 30, 2006

Derb & God

John Derbyshire has a very interesting "Faith FAQ" online, in which, among other things, he declares himself a Mysterian. One of the things that I find interesting is that he continually refers to his Mysterian beliefs as a loss of faith. Yet, it seems to me that Mysterianism is the very essence of Judaism! John describes it like this:

My God is at, or possibly just is, one pole of the great two-poled mystery of everything: the origin of the universe, which passeth all human understanding. He is the Creator. Since He was present in the cosmos then, I assume He is now (or “now,” since He is obviously outside spacetime); and since I can apprehend Him, I assume He is aware of me. The two poles of mystery, the Him and the Me (I mean, the invidual human consciousness, the I, the Me — that’s the second pole) are in contact somehow, and may actually be the same thing...

In fact, I agree with most of what John says in his FAQs (the part about Catholicism being a major exception) - which mostly chronicles the things he has learned which led him away from religion. Yet, I find none of it even remotely challenging to my religion. It makes me feel very lucky, being a Mysterian from birth.

Posted by David Boxenhorn at October 30, 2006 10:41 PM | TrackBacks
Comments & Trackbacks

Hello David,

My last post is also about the God question. Given the fact that I have overcame my lazy mediterranean character and I wrote it in English perhaps you would be interested in having a look.


It is fine to have rishon-rishon back!

Posted by: Kantor at November 7, 2006 09:56 AM Permalink

Thanks, Kantor. I don't know if I'm back, though.

I enjoyed your post. For me, I just think that we can prove God by making Him (by definition) the answer to some paradoxical questions, like:

Why/how does anything exist?
Why this existence and not some other?
What is consciousness?

Posted by: David Boxenhorn at November 7, 2006 12:25 PM Permalink

× Network: